Removing an executor or trustee can be a complex but necessary step to ensure the proper administration of an estate or trust. While the roles of executor and trustee may sometimes be held by the same person, they are legally distinct, and the grounds and procedures for removal differ. In this post, we’ll explore why you might want to remove them, the limitations to removal, and what happens if they die or lose capacity.
Why Might You Want to Remove an Executor or Trustee?
Misconduct or Breach of Duty: If the executor or trustee has mismanaged the estate or trust, acted dishonestly, or failed to follow the terms of the will or trust, removal may be necessary.
Conflict of Interest: If the individual is in a position where their interests conflict with those of the estate or trust, it can lead to biased decisions that harm the beneficiaries.
Incapacity or Unfitness to Act: If the executor or trustee is no longer capable of carrying out their duties due to age, illness, or incompetence, their removal may be required to protect the estate or trust.
Non-Cooperation or Communication Breakdown: If the executor or trustee is not cooperating with other executors, trustees, or beneficiaries, it can impede the effective management of the estate or trust.
Beneficiaries’ Interests at Risk: If the executor or trustee’s actions are putting the beneficiaries’ interests at risk, such as by neglecting to collect or safeguard assets, removal may be necessary to protect those interests.
On What Basis Can You Not Remove an Executor or Trustee?
Minor Disagreements: Minor disagreements or personality clashes with beneficiaries or co-trustees are generally not sufficient grounds for removal.
Actions within Legal Rights: If the executor or trustee is carrying out their duties within the boundaries of the law and the terms of the will or trust, even if some beneficiaries disagree with their decisions, they cannot be removed.
Beneficiaries' Preference: Personal preference or the desire of beneficiaries to have a different executor or trustee is not usually a valid reason for removal unless there is clear evidence of wrongdoing or mismanagement.
What Happens If an Executor or Trustee Dies or Loses Capacity?
Executor’s Death or Incapacity:
If an executor dies or loses capacity before the estate is fully administered, a substitute executor may be appointed, either named in the will or by the court. If there is no substitute named, beneficiaries may apply for a grant of letters of administration with the will annexed.
Trustee’s Death or Incapacity:
If a trustee dies or becomes incapacitated, the trust deed will usually specify how a new trustee is to be appointed. If not, the remaining trustees or the beneficiaries may appoint a new trustee under the Trustee Act 1925.
Court Involvement:
In both cases, if the appointment process is unclear or disputed, the court can be asked to intervene and appoint a suitable person to take over the responsibilities.
How to Approach the Removal Process
Consult Legal Advice: The first step is to seek legal advice to understand the implications of removing an executor or trustee, and whether you have sufficient grounds for their removal.
Consider Mediation: Before going to court, consider whether mediation or a formal meeting might resolve the issues without the need for removal.
Court Application: If removal is necessary, you will need to make an application to the court, providing evidence that the executor or trustee’s continued involvement is harming the estate or trust.
Conclusion
Removing an executor or trustee is not a decision to be taken lightly. It requires clear evidence and a thorough understanding of the legal processes involved. If you’re facing difficulties with an executor or trustee, or if you’re concerned about the proper administration of an estate or trust, contact us at Toucan Law for professional advice and support. We’re here to help you navigate these complex issues with care and expertise.
Comments